After the successful run with JMeter earlier to load test our web pages, I have been on a mission to find an open source tool to automate our GUI application. So far, I have not found any good (free) open source tool. But, I stumbled upon several nice tools and scripting languages to automate windows GUI application.
JMeter was very good for the Web. Since each web page can be generated (HTML), the tool could simulate page to page navigation well. If only we can do this for the GUI screens? It’s all compiled code and a GUI doesn’t look like it can be tampered with (until I found below scripts). So, you essentially need to work on it like a black box, so you can automate a GUI application only by capturing it’s external interfaces – mouse clicks, keys types and windows messages to and from the application.
I started with Sikuli. This is a great tool/script. It’s Python based and lets you capture screen shots of different parts of the screen and drive your script by looking for these images. They call it Computer Vision. You can build a library of standard images (For e.g., Button with the label OK) and reuse them across the application(s). As long as your application has GUI standards, this will work out great. It’s a great concept and it seems to work decently.
Sikuli IDE lets you capture screenshots from within and use these in functions For e.g., wait function, waits for a screen matching the screenshot to appear. After you create your script in IDE and save it, the underlying script is actually saved as a Python script, with the all the images saved.
Sikuli has a full array of built in (global) functions. See documentation for more.
Note: Above script has UDF – user defined functions. When you record script through AutoIt3 Recorder, it will have one long script. I’ve divided these into functions.
Sikuli is a great tool. It deserves more research and I reserve it for future. I am more of a scripting guy and I like text based scripts. (It’s easier to find and replace globally and you can even write a script to generate another). So, I continued my search for my text based scripting language. Also, I had some issue with the installation. Though it worked initially, the runtime (a batch file running Java jar) kept getting corrupted for some reason. Then I tried their portable version, it seemed to work OK so far. But, if you are having issues with Sikuli installation, please see here, here, here, here. I did not see any recorder for Sikuli, though I saw references to one all over the web.
Then I landed on AutoIt. It’s great tool. I’ve really grown to like it. It has a BASIC kind of language (actually more like PERL, C etc) and lets you program everything from mouse clicks to taking complete control of a GUI application window. Apparently original AutoIt reached version 2 and stopped. There is a new branch called AutoIt3. This version is bigger and better than previous versions. See here for full history of the product.
AutoIt3 scripts can be edited in integrated Scite Editor. All popular editors like Notepad++ also support Autoscript syntax. AutoIt3 comes with a Recorder as well. I was able to run our application and record it into a script that I could use repeatedly. I am just beginning to explore this tool. I will post more as I explore the tool further.
Fig 3 AutoIt3 Script edited in Notepadd++
When you install AutoIt3, the commands are integrated into Windows Explorer menu. You can edit or Run script from here. Edit opens Scite Editor by default.
AutoIt site has a very good forum with lots of skilled people supporting it. A section called “Example Scripts” provides lots of good sample scripts. For a real dive into AutoIt3, take a look at a script called Control Viewer. The author has taken the pains to develop it in AutoIt3 itself. It shows you how to create GUI in Autoscript, and using this you can identify controls (widgets) on any windows application currently running. (AutoIt3 comes with AutoInfo which has similar functionality, but CV has it better!). For some reason the author has discontinued it, but you can down the EXE and the scripts from the main page.
The third product I looked at, but haven’t done much with, is AutoHotKey (AHK). Apparently it combines strengths of 2 different programs, AutoIt (older version) and Hotkey. One immediate observation about AHK scripts was that it didn’t look as structured as AutoIt scripts. But, I could be wrong. There are debates about AutoIt vs AHK. See here for a comparison, though somewhat old. AutoIt3 wins hands down for me at the moment.
I will post more as I explore any of these tools for use in test automation. If you are interested, here are some interesting links about the topic: